Home / News / Adjust the benchmarks for faith-based funds: ASFA

Adjust the benchmarks for faith-based funds: ASFA

ASFA wants the YFYS performance test benchmarks tweaked to account for the exclusions and negative screens that faith- and values-based funds use.
News

While the Treasury consultation suggests applying a supplementary test to faith-based products that have failed the performance test, ASFA (headed up by Martin Fahy, photo at top) believes this would create the perception that they had been granted “special treatment” and that the main test should instead be overhauled to account for it.

ASFA says this approach was likely adopted in order to minimize work for APRA, but that accepting the premise of benchmarking in the first place suggests that there should be only one “appropriately constructed benchmark against which any such assessment is made.”

“If a product has made a “values-based” or “principles-based” decision not to invest in one or more assets then it is not appropriate to assess that product against a benchmark that includes the performance of those assets,” ASFA said in its submission to the consultation. “Instead, the benchmark should be adjusted by removing those assets and the product assessed against the adjusted benchmark.”

“By way of example, if a product has decided not to invest in tobacco products, or armaments, or gambling, because of the deleterious effect on public and individual health, the relevant benchmark(s) should be adjusted by removing the performance of those products from that benchmark.”

ASFA agrees with the proposition that trustees should be required to apply to APRA with respect to their product status in order to have their performance test adjusted, but suggests that the scope of Treasury’s review into the treatment of faith-based funds should be broadened to include all “values-based” products that impose limitations on investing in certain assets.

The performance test could then be adjusted for the product based on the trustee certifying that it employs a “‘values-based’, or “principles-based” investment strategy, that is disclosed to its members in its regulated disclosures and marketing materials, and has, as a question of fact, employed particular filters/screens.”

Staff Writer


  • Related
    ‘My performance doesn’t lie’: Liu responds to relationship revelations

    The romantic relationship between TenCap founders Jun Bei Liu and Jason Todd has exploded into the press, but Liu tells Investor Strategy News that her personal life has nothing to do with the running of her Alpha Plus fund.

    Lachlan Maddock | 11th Feb 2025 | More
    TelstraSuper CIO heads (back) to Mercer

    Industry veteran Graeme Miller will step into the chief investment officer job at Mercer Super after a nearly nine year stint at TelstraSuper where he played a “pivotal role” in shaping its investment strategy and approach to sustainable investing.

    Lachlan Maddock | 7th Feb 2025 | More
    Fidelity looks to niche assets, new clients for diversification

    The race to the bottom on low cost, benchmark aware solutions for a post-YFYS world has pretty much been run. But while the perception of value currently sits on price, that might not be where it ends up, according to Fidelity’s Simon Glazier.

    Lachlan Maddock | 5th Feb 2025 | More
    Popular