Home / News / Super returns flash red – but it’s not all bad news

Super returns flash red – but it’s not all bad news


While most super funds will deliver their members a negative return this year amidst an indiscriminate selloff, they remain well ahead of their long-term objectives.

Up until the end of May, returns for the financial year to date “were pretty flat”. But by close-of-business Friday (June 17) a median growth fund would have returned negative five per cent – and given the large daily fluctuations we’re now seeing, the final result could be “meaningfully different”, says Chant West senior investment research manager Mano Mohankumar.

It’ll be the first negative return many members have seen, and will represent only the fifth negative return since the introduction of compulsory super in 1992. The average loss in the Covid market downturn was -0.6 per cent, though many funds successfully struggled to get their members something in the green.

While the expectation is usually that growth options will be punished the most, conservative the least, the indiscriminate nature of the sell-off – which has touched everything from bonds to growthy tech stocks – means the differential won’t be that great, with Mohankumar estimating about one per cent difference.

But it’s not all bad news. Most funds continue to meet their long-term return objectives by a significant amount, with the median growth fund returning seven per cent per annum compared to an annual CPI increase over the same period of 2.5 per cent. Still, any dislocation in equity market raises the possibility that previously disengaged members will start making bad decisions.

Last week, a panel of CIOs convened at the AIST’s superannuation investment conference warned that funds would need to go “back to basics” to communicate the downturn to members in order to prevent the sort of switching that went on at the bottom of the Covid market.

“I think it’s important that members see things in context,” Mohankumar said. “This return comes on the back of a median growth return of 18 per cent last year, and that’s the second highest single-year return since the introduction of compulsory super in 1992… But even factoring in the large losses in June so far, the median growth fund is still five per cent ahead of the pre-Covid high at the end of January 2020.”

“More importantly, funds continue to meet their long-term return objectives by some way. We’d just caution members about the perils of attempting to time the market; that whole plan of switching to cash and switching back later is going to result in an inferior outcome… Getting distracted

While Chant West hasn’t calculated the YFYS benchmarks for each investment option, Mohankumar says it will be “interesting to see how active management has done this month.” But on that front, new research from research house Super Ratings for the year to 31 March forecasts that some 20 per cent of Choice options will fail the performance test, with options comprised of 91-100 per cent growth assets most likely to fail based on performance over the past eight years.

Around a quarter of “stable” options comprised of 20-40 per cent growth assets are also expected to fail, with more MySuper products also set to underperform by more than the 50 basis point leeway.
“The first performance test has had a significant impact on the future of those products which failed,” the research house wrote. “Having an industry wide benchmark gives funds a clear target with significant potential benefit for members, however ensuring the test is appropriately capturing the nuances of the range of investment options in the industry remains a challenge.”

Print Article

’60/40 is being resuscitated’: fixed income down but not out

Year-to-date, fixed income markets are about as bad as equities. But Michael Leithead, fixed income and senior portfolio manager at EFG Asset Management (EFGAM), is more positive than he’s been “in a long time.” “We’re at a point now where the market has priced in quite a lot of global policy tightening, and that restores…

Lachlan Maddock | 24th Jun 2022 | More
‘It’s a business about character’: Kudu hunts deals Down Under

New York-based Kudu Investment Management has returned to Australia in hopes of pulling off a repeat of its 2020 deal with Channel Capital. “The asset management business is an absolutely beautiful business, to the mind of anybody involved in it. It’s rock solid; it has high margins; and the people are interesting,” says Charlie Ruffel,…

Lachlan Maddock | 24th Jun 2022 | More
APRA grows concerned on consolidation, flags new standards

The wave of consolidation racing through the superannuation industry is now raising eyebrows at the prudential regulator. With the massive amounts of FUM being devoured, some funds are suffering indigestion. “This may manifest at the industry level at the point of transfer in a SFT, for example where an administrator has a backlog of transfers…

Lachlan Maddock | 24th Jun 2022 | More
News and OneVue go live with brightday
Investor Strategy News | 11th Jan 2015 | More
Perrignon off to HK with Credit Suisse
Investor Strategy News | 22nd Dec 2013 | More
Sports betting as a new asset class
Investor Strategy News | 3rd Jul 2016 | More
BlackRock ahead of consensus with bullish view
Investor Strategy News | 14th Jan 2017 | More
HSBC talks re-open old NAB wound
Lachlan Maddock | 9th Mar 2022 | More
Statewide seeds bespoke Apostle fund
Lachlan Maddock | 23rd Mar 2022 | More