Home / Analysis / What really matters in alternatives manager selection

What really matters in alternatives manager selection

High returns help, but what’s more important is trust, accountability, and making sure that the remuneration structures aren’t “really cheeky”.
Analysis

When it’s time to add a new manager to the portfolio, the first metric most investors look at is returns – and for good reason.  

But it’s not just about whether a manager can deliver for the portfolio, but whether you can build trust with them, according to Chloé Brayne, head of private equity and unlisted assets at Colonial First State (pictured middle).

“Can you trust them to deliver what you think they’re going to do?” Brayne told The Inside Network’s Alternative’s Symposium. “We spend a lot of time with managers looking to understand that as part of the diligence process. There’s obviously a really rigorous selection framework that looks at historic al performance, but also what you’re expecting them to do going forward.”

  • Part of that trust comes from understanding exactly how they’re incentivised – especially in alternatives, where remuneration structures can be at best complex, and at worst inscrutable – and another part from governance.

    “Do they have people on the ground in Australia, people that you can call up to get accountability from? What does that reporting framework look like? Are you getting enough information coming through on the underlying stock selection so that you can make a decision if they’re performing and if they’re delivering what you’re expecting them to for the portfolio? Governance is really important for us because of our scale and size. We’re able to get really strong positions and really good visibility through that reporting.”

    Good manager selection mostly means disregarding the pitch deck, said Daniel Kelly, partner and head of alternative investments at Kelly+Partners Private Wealth (pictured right), because “every pitch deck is amazing”.

    “Having a face-to-face conversation with the manager will tell you a lot that the marketing material probably hides, and we implement that as part of our due diligence process,” Kelly said.  “And the incentives point is crucial with alts, because you can get some really cheeky performance reward structures that are kind of inherently at odds with what the manager is trying to do, particularly in private credit.”

    “So we kind of steer away from managers that have performance fees with really low hurdles, because it kind of inherently incentivises them to take risk and to generate excess return when maybe their job is just to produce stable income.”

    But there’s more to performance than just the return, Brayne said.

    “I’d be looking at the drivers of how they got that return. Was it just buying low, selling high? Were they bringing something else to the picture? And sometimes that’s okay – just buying in the cycle. But if you think your manager is actually supposed to be driving operational value then you might take a step back and go ‘Well is this manager actually delivering what we thought they would for the portfolio?’”

    “Obviously we get a lot of pitches and a lot of managers coming through. I’m always interested in what makes them different to everybody else. What can that manager deliver that just doesn’t look like everything else in the market?”  

    Lachlan Maddock

    Lachlan is editor of Investor Strategy News and has extensive experience covering institutional investment.




    Print Article

    Related
    Politics, tech, climate put asset owners in new risk territory

    Large asset owners will need to develop a new risk management approach amid increasingly fraught political and investment conditions, according to a new Thinking Ahead Institute study.

    David Chaplin | 4th Dec 2024 | More
    How to find hedge funds investing in ‘dynamism and change’: Panel

    There’s around 15,000 hedge funds in the world – but how many of them are really hedge funds? When you’re looking for non- or less-correlated returns, it might pay to stay away from a long bias.

    Lachlan Maddock | 27th Nov 2024 | More
    For total portfolio approach to succeed, funds need more than good intentions

    Funds that want to take the total portfolio approach first need to get the total portfolio view. To do that they not only need data – and lots of it – but a rock-solid understanding of exactly how they’re going to use it.

    Lachlan Maddock | 22nd Nov 2024 | More
    Popular