Home / Analysis / Private markets dragged pension performance in 2023: CEM Benchmarking

Private markets dragged pension performance in 2023: CEM Benchmarking

Global pension funds posted an atypical aggregate net below-benchmark annual investment performance during 2023, with the shortfall largely attributable to increased use of private markets assets.
Analysis

New figures from CEM Benchmarking found the average net value added (NVA) of the US$14 trillion of pension fund money it tracks fell into the red for the “first time in a decade” over the previous calendar year.

The CEM data shows the average NVA, defined as gross returns less all costs versus fund-selected benchmarks, landed at -1.4 per cent across the global pension scheme universe. Close to 80 per cent of all pension funds covered by the Toronto-headquartered researcher reported a below-zero NVA in 2023 but retain a positive long-term record.

“This brought the ten-year average NVA (18 bps) closer in-line with the average since CEM’s inception in 1992 (i.e.,17 bps),” CEM group chief Rashay Jethalal said in a note, adding that growing pension fund exposure to private markets largely explained the poor relative performance last year.

  • “More specifically, it is the NVA in private equity (materially negative) and real assets (modestly negative). This was amplified by the fact that private market investment has increased from 12 per cent of AUM in 2014 to 24 per cent in 2023,” Jethalal said. “By the way, public markets had a strong year in terms of beta but were unable to generate positive NVA to offset private markets.”

    The CEM study also shows individual pension fund investors saw net above-benchmark 10-year returns from actively managed strategies in most asset classes even as indexing options soared.

    “Interestingly, over the decade, we saw U.S. DC (defined contribution) plan participants actually get less access to active investment options,” Jethalal said. “For example, in 2014, 14 per cent of U.S. DC plans offered passive equity options to their members. In 2023 this number increased to 25 per cent.”

    At the same time, CEM found two-thirds of all pension schemes in its purview have reduced post-inflation administration costs over the last decade by an average 0.4 per cent each year. During the same 10-year period, almost 90 per cent of pension funds improved their CEM-measured service scores with an average annual increase of 1.5 per cent across the sector.

    CEM attributes the mix of lower-costs and better-service to the digitalisation trend that has seen the use of secure member-accessible websites rise from 50 per cent 20 years ago to 80 per cent today.

    The Canadian-founded researcher provides investment and administration benchmarking services to more than 400 pension

    David Chaplin

    David Chaplin is a reputed financial services journalist and publisher of Investment News NZ.




    Print Article

    Related
    Investors on red alert despite inflation being tamed: Atlantic House

    Central banks have performed admirably to get economies back on track, but a public that is far less-trusting of big institutions and traditional asset classes remains unconvinced. US President Donald Trump’s trade policies are simply fuelling their fears.

    Nicholas Way | 21st Mar 2025 | More
    Welcome to the brave new world of higher, more volatile inflation: Ruffer

    A high US January CPI number rattled the markets before the Producer Price Index (PPI) calmed investor waters. A closer look at the data, however, shows a far from rosy picture, especially with President Donald Trump’s policies likely to push prices higher.

    Giorgio Curti | 14th Mar 2025 | More
    Beware unbridled animal spirits: Ruffer

    A world where animal spirits are running wild is also one that has temporarily divorced from fundamentals. Experience tells us this often doesn’t end well. 

    Oliver Shale | 27th Feb 2025 | More
    Popular