Home / Texas pension fund considers psych tests on managers

Texas pension fund considers psych tests on managers

(pictured: Christopher Schelling)

A big US pension fund is investigating the use of personality and aptitude tests for fund managers to become part of its due diligence process. The fund’s head of private equity investments, Christopher Schelling, has written a paper explaining the rationale.

Schelling, the director of private equity at the Texas Municipal Retirement System, had the paper published on Asset International’s daily ‘CIO’ newsletter late last month.

  • He says that the three ‘I’s – Intelligence, Integrity and Intensity – which he terms 3i”, are the most important character traits in a fund manager.

    He says: “Numerous private-sector firms have long utilized such tests for direct hiring decisions, as have many government agencies for certain types of critical contractors. “Since hiring managers is really all about hiring people, the parallels are obvious. Psychometric tests are far from perfect, but have been shown to be reasonably accurate. And in addition to scoring cognitive ability and measuring select personality traits, they often test for internal consistency and can highlight individuals engaging in self-promotion and potential prevarication.

    “At the very least, tests provide hard data and a means to objectively quantify inputs in an otherwise purely subjective and qualitative process.

    “For me, that process is identifying managers who are high 3i. The biggest hurdle will be adoption by prospective managers, particularly the ones that are access-constrained.”

    Investor Strategy News


    Related
    Editor’s note: For members, it’s no longer all about the money

    If 2024 showed us anything, it’s that super funds have to become more than accumulation machines if they want to maintain their status as the trusted guarantors of most Australians’ financial future.

    Lachlan Maddock | 18th Dec 2024 | More
    How to stop worrying and learn to live with (if not love) tariffs

    A second Trump presidency and the potential for a new US trade regime increases uncertainty as we head into 2025. But despite the prevailing zeitgeist of unease, emerging market investors have various reasons to be sanguine, according to Ninety One

    Alan Siow | 18th Dec 2024 | More
    Why investors should beware the Trump bump

    Tweets aren’t policy, but Yarra Capital believes that financial markets are underestimating Trump’s intentions. Expect 2025 to be the year of higher debt, higher inflation and lower growth – not to mention plenty of volatility.

    Lachlan Maddock | 13th Dec 2024 | More
    Popular