Home / Analysis / The one thing China has that Japan didn’t

The one thing China has that Japan didn’t

Everybody’s worried that the world’s largest economy will suffer the same fate as Japan did when its asset price bubble collapsed in the late 80s. But, like it or not, China has one big advantage.
Analysis

As concerns grow that China’s economy will remain sluggish and that the country will experience “Japan-ification”, counterarguments have focused on the smaller size of the asset price bubble in China and the pre-emptive actions taken to deflate it. But according to Elaine Tse, portfolio manager Total Emerging Markets team at Allspring Global Investments, China has one thing that Japan lacked.

“It’s an authoritarian regime,” Tse says. “It can change on a dime. We saw that with Covid. And so now that they recognise that they’ve been too conservative with their policies and risk going into a multi-year L-shaped recovery they can swing from being restrained to very aggressive very quickly.”

“Japan’s a constitutional monarchy with a democratic system; you always get pushback from opposition parties. Or it take s along time for the banks to say that they’ll recognise non-performing loans and it takes a long time for stimulus bills to be passed. But China can clear the decks immediately.”

  • And even “traditional China sceptics” – those who have always been suspicious of the economic data that flows from its government, the weak banking system and the ghost cities that were built 8-10 years ago – wonder if the worst case scenario isn’t already built in.

    “China banks are trading at 0.3 times book and nine per cent yield,” Tse says. “Alibaba is at under 10 times earnings. So we think much of that negativity is in price; we’re cautiously optimistic on the new policies that are being introduced, and the macro numbers – the PMI, retail sales growth, fixed asset investment – are starting to pace slightly above expectations.”

    “And this is before a slew of policies have been introduced. For the full year we’re hopeful that China can achieve five per cent growth. The current environment, with weak expectations, is an opportunity. We’re underweight in China and we’re looking for opportunities to reduce that underweight.”

    Allspring anticipates that the wider emerging market set will soon emerge from the decade-long doldrums they’ve found themselves in. And while it hasn’t happened yet, valuation dispersion and institutional underweights give Tse some hope that a different dynamic will reign in the next decade.

    We know that discounted valuations alone don’t argue for outperformance going forward; it’s really the valuation differential combined with the fact that we’re now hitting this inflection point for EM growth to DM growth that’s starting to expand,” Tse says.

    “Add to that the fact that EM is very under-owned by global institutional investors. The current allocation to ACWI is about six per cent, whereas neutral is about 11.5 per cent – so investors are half-weighted. Ten years ago those figures stood at nine and 10 per cent respectively. That really shows how negative sentiment has been towards EM – so we’re very constructive.”

    Lachlan Maddock

    Lachlan is editor of Investor Strategy News and has extensive experience covering institutional investment.




    Print Article

    Related
    How to stop worrying and learn to live with (if not love) tariffs

    A second Trump presidency and the potential for a new US trade regime increases uncertainty as we head into 2025. But despite the prevailing zeitgeist of unease, emerging market investors have various reasons to be sanguine, according to Ninety One

    Alan Siow | 18th Dec 2024 | More
    Why investors should beware the Trump bump

    Tweets aren’t policy, but Yarra Capital believes that financial markets are underestimating Trump’s intentions. Expect 2025 to be the year of higher debt, higher inflation and lower growth – not to mention plenty of volatility.

    Lachlan Maddock | 13th Dec 2024 | More
    How to get a ‘return on time’ in private markets

    Private market returns are nothing to sneeze at, but investors need to consider whether their prospective allocation is worth doing the hard work to understand the liquidity and transparency issues that come with it.

    Lachlan Maddock | 13th Dec 2024 | More
    Popular