Home / Analysis / A growing debt pile could signal the return of bond vigilantes

A growing debt pile could signal the return of bond vigilantes

Unrest in the Middle East, political dysfunction in Washington and the looming shadow of a global recession means markets face a new wall of worry in time for the holiday season.
Analysis

In the United States, the removal of the sitting Speaker of the House, Kevin McCarthy “dramatically increases” the probability that the US government will be shut down in mid-November, according to Allspring Global Investment’s latest Allview Risk Monitor. A prolonged government shutdown right before the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays would be disastrous for both retail sales and travel, and could push the US economy into recession.

That in part begets a new addition to Allspring’s risk list: a potential return of the bond vigilantes.
Bond vigilantes are traders who sell or threaten to sell large amounts of bonds to protest the policies of their issuer. The political dysfunction in Washington, massive debt and deficit levels that continuously need to be refinanced, and Fitch’s recent downgrade of the US credit rating is enough to give any holders of U.S government debt “pause”.

“The risk here is that the pause turns into a protest that leads to a failed Treasury auction and an instantaneous spike higher in the yields of long-dated US Treasury bonds,” writes Allspring’s Investment Analytics team. “… Portfolios overweight US duration could experience significant underperformance relative to their benchmarks.”

  • The possibility of a shooting conflict between NATO and Russia still looms large, as does a global recession, with many of the major world economies “exhibiting signs of economic contraction”. And while markets so far seem unperturbed by it, it’s impossible to ignore the risks that arise from the ongoing war between Israel and Hamas. Iran is “universally considered” the financial and military backer of the recent attacks on Israel, while Iranian naval vessels have seized multiple oil tankers this year in the Persian Gulf.

    “While the human death toll is staggering, our mandate is to focus on how these actions could affect global markets,” the team wrote. “Given that, we’ve re-added our previous concern relating to a military strike on Iran. It’s highly likely that Israel will seek to hold Iran accountable for the actions of Hamas. Any military strike on Iran will likely lead to a dramatic rise in the price of crude oil.”

    Staff Writer


    Related
    Being selective, risk aware, flexible critical in today’s markets: Ninety One

    While the repercussions from ‘Liberation Day’ are still playing out, there can be little doubt it’s a more complex investment environment in which macro conditions, policy actions and asset-level fundamentals will interact in increasingly idiosyncratic ways.

    Ninety One Investment Institute | 24th Apr 2025 | More
    Turbulent markets will suit commercial real estate: Analysts

    Listed property, which found investor favour in 2024, is better positioned to weather market volatility with institutions eyeing improving valuations and development opportunities. For overseas players, a weaker Australian dollar is a bonus.

    Duncan Hughes | 28th Mar 2025 | More
    Investors on red alert despite inflation being tamed: Atlantic House

    Central banks have performed admirably to get economies back on track, but a public that is far less-trusting of big institutions and traditional asset classes remains unconvinced. US President Donald Trump’s trade policies are simply fuelling their fears.

    Nicholas Way | 21st Mar 2025 | More
    Popular