Home / News / Super funds ‘neglecting’ forestry: Atchison Consultants

Super funds ‘neglecting’ forestry: Atchison Consultants

Forestry has investment features that dovetail with the long-term strategies of super funds, according to Atchison Consultants, but the asset class has been ignored in favour of more traditional allocations .
News

The stable, regular returns of forestry – and the outperformance of its index relative to the Your Future Your Super (YFYS) property benchmark – make it a fine addition to super fund portfolios, according to a new research paper from Atchison Consultants, but forestry has been “neglected” by funds.

“Although forestry is illiquid by nature, requiring long-term planting, nurturing, and harvesting spanning many years, that timeframe can be accommodated by funds that have the capacity to measure investments over decades, not years,” said Kevin Toohey, principal at Atchison Consulting.

The paper, commissioned by UK-based alts manager Gresham House, found that forestry is more correlated to property than infrastructure owing to its ownership structure, use patterns, and lifecycle and depreciation. But while it’s similar to property, its index – the US NCREIF Timberland Property Index – outperformed the YFYS property benchmark (MSCI/Mercer Australian Core Wholesale Monthly Property Fund Index Net Total Return Module) over the last five years.

  • “It offers income generation opportunities, can benefit from capital appreciation, offers an inflation hedge and provides asset diversification by often exhibiting a low correlation with traditional asset classes such as stocks and bonds, thereby mitigating overall portfolio risk,” Toohey said. “Investment in timber can have significant environmental implications, with responsible timber practices contributing to sustainable development and carbon sequestration.”

    Over a 16-year period, the YFYS property index outperformed the NCREIF though the NCREIF was more resilient during periods of extreme market upheaval, including the GFC, where it “outperformed strongly”. It also outperformed during periods of low supply and high demand for timber, including in 2007, 2012-2014, 2021 and 2022, and has a superior risk/return aspect with a Sharpe ratio of 1.31 vs the YFYS benchmark at 1.21.

    “Forestry has outperformed mainstream asset classes over the last four decades on a risk-adjusted basis, driven by increases in land values and timber prices as well as an investor base demanding sustainability,” said Dave Gardner, forestry CIO at Gresham House.

    Lachlan Maddock

    Lachlan is editor of Investor Strategy News and has extensive experience covering institutional investment.




    Print Article

    Related
    Megafunds split on future of YFYS

    Australia’s biggest super funds disagree on what the new Your Future, Your Super performance test should look like, but they both think the consequences for failure should be just as weighty – and apply to everybody equally.

    Lachlan Maddock | 26th Apr 2024 | More
    Australian Retirement Trust joins the jet set

    The $280 billion ART has become the latest megafund to set up an offshore outpost as it looks to secure “even more compelling investment opportunities” for its 2.3 million members.

    Staff Writer | 26th Apr 2024 | More
    What to do about the ‘concentration conundrum’: Pzena

    Owning the largest stocks has historically been a recipe for underperformance over every period, according to value house Pzena, but the madness of benchmark construction means some investors have few choices but to.

    Staff Writer | 19th Apr 2024 | More
    Popular